Photo by Liv Cashman on Unsplash
Graphic elements by Ken Silbert
Photo by Liv Cashman on Unsplash
Graphic elements by Ken Silbert
Indigenous Peoples' Day caught me unprepared today. When I can, I like to find a good sentence related to a period of observance, read the entire book, and write my blog post to suit. If you'd like to read about a sentence from an indigenous author today, please consider my older posts on Empire of Wild, Two Roads, Trail of Lightning, or Solar Flares.
Mr. Midshipman Hornblower is part of the influential Horatio Hornblower series by C. S. Forester. I'd heard "Horatio Hornblower stories" frequently as a shorthand for tales of people who start with very little and work hard to gain status and wealth. I was a little surprised to learn this book came out in 1950 – I'd gained an impression that the books had been around longer. As it turns out, C. S. Forester wrote the series out of chronological order. Mr. Midshipman Hornblower covers the beginning of Hornblower's career, but the earliest publication in the series came in 1937. This makes Forester a contemporary of Hemingway.
The story begins in 1796, and the first sentence has some flavor of that time. Forester paid attention to the sound of the words. Notice the sets of alliteration (words that start with the same consonants): "blustering loudly, and bearing on its bosom," "duties kept them on deck." He repeated the word "loudly." In the second phrase that contains it, "big drops rattled loudly" the strong beats of the rhythm (´, ´, ´-, ´-) thump like the raindrops do. The sentence lends itself to reading aloud, with varying rhythms and repeating sounds.
Reading it aloud also makes it easier to understand. With only two commas in thirty-nine words, the sentence could use the vocal expression of a good reader to help group the words into meaning. My first read put pauses in the sentence this way: "A January gale was roaring up the Channel,/ blustering loudly,/ and bearing on its bosom/ rain squalls/ whose big drops rattled loudly/ on the tarpaulin clothing/ of those among the officers/ and men/ whose duties kept them on deck." That's not the best division to make the sentence clear. Especially, the break after "officers" causes a hitch when parsing the sentence. A reader who already knew the sentence, and read without pause through "those among the officers and men" would make this easier to follow. Then we see that a storm brought rain that fell upon the sailors.
A fair number of the words relate to the sea: gale, Channel, squalls, tarpaulin, deck. Some of the phrases sound old-fashioned: blustering, bearing on its bosom, tarpaulin (again), officers and men. The sounds and connotations of the words help build a mood – a little poetic, a little historic.
This is a nostalgic sentence. It looks back to a time that some found heroic and appealing: when men (only men) stood up to the gusts of nature, and won their place by their own efforts. That's not really how we see the world any more.
So maybe, this Indigenous Peoples' Day, this sentence can serve as a reminder of a past we no longer admire so simply.
Graphic elements by Ken Silbert
Photo by Tyler Lastovich on Unsplash
Note: Corrected apostrophe placement in Indigenous Peoples' Day on 12 Oct. 2021.
Jennifer Crusie's novel, Welcome to Temptation, was the first contemporary romance I absolutely loved. She published it in 2000 and I read it a few years later. Rereading it last year, I again admired the craft and the humor and the characters, even while noticing that quite a lot has changed since it came out.
The first sentence of Welcome to Temptation is: "Sophie Dempsey didn’t like Temptation even before the Garveys smashed into her ’86 Civic, broke her sister’s sunglasses, and confirmed all her worst suspicions about people from small towns who drove beige Cadillacs. "
It's a long sentence. Like the first sentence of Last Looks (which I blogged about on Aug. 23rd), it has a careful structure to help the meaning stay clear.
The first part of the sentence could be complete in itself: "Sophie Dempsey didn't like Temptation." That gives us a person, Sophie Dempsey; a problem – she doesn't like Temptation; and an interesting double entendre – we see "Temptation" the capitalized name, and we also hear "temptation" the invitation to do something one shouldn't. Sophie may well face two things she doesn't like.
The rest of the sentence intensifies Sophie's dislike. The words "even before" mean that whatever follows will make things worse. Then Crusie piles on the extra layers of problem: "the Garveys smashed into her '86 Civic, broke her sister's sunglasses, and confirmed all her worst suspicions about people from small towns who drove beige Cadillacs." One interesting technique here is that the problems, instead of moving from small to large instead start with the worst and grow increasingly trivial. Smashing into a car is a potentially lethal problem. Breaking sunglasses is physical damage, but to something small and easy to replace. Confirming suspicions happens entirely within Sophie's head – it is perhaps no damage at all. And what is she suspicious about? Small towns and beige Cadillacs – items which many find attractive rather than suspicious.
The sentence, instead of increasing the tension by making the situation worse and worse, reassures us – because if breaking her sister's sunglasses is the worst damage of the car accident, no one was hurt – and then becomes absurd as Sophie worries about small towns and Cadillacs. The final result is humor rather than tragedy.
The sentence does raise questions. Why does Sophie dislike Temptation? Why is she suspicious of small towns and people who drive Cadillacs? Or is it only people who drive beige Cadillacs? What will happen next? But it asks those questions with humor and curiosity rather than fear and high tension.
We also learn quite a lot about Sophie, the time, and the setting. Sophie has an old and cheap car, and a sister. Her car dates from '86, and it's a year when beige is fashionable, which narrows down the time. They are in a small town, where at least one family, the Garveys, drives a Cadillac. These details are the first elements of the story's world. They don't say everything about the time or place, but they do begin to suggest where and when the Garveys hit Sophie's car.
I appreciate the humor, the attitude, and the commas in this sentence. Since I like humor, attitude, and well-placed commas, I am entirely tempted to read on.
Graphic elements by Ken Silbert
Photo by Endri Killo on Unsplash
No first sentence this week! I am on vacation.
I believe in vacations! Be kind to yourselves this week.
The first sentence of Neil Gaiman's Anansi Boys is: "It begins, as most things begin, with a song."
The tension here is in the word "begins." Something is beginning. We don't yet know what. We don't know what characters will face it. We don't know where or when. So far, we have very few details.
The next phrase, "as most things begin," is a statement about the shape of the world. It claims that most things that begin all start in the same way. Most things are alike. There is pattern to the universe. This is a not exactly a creation myth, but a statement of faith about creations: Most things have the same genesis.
The last phrase is "with a song." The word "song" falls in the strong, final position, but it is not a word that increases tension. A song is art rather than danger. This placement shows that songs are important – Gaiman uses the last word to emphasize creation rather than suspense.
Perhaps that is why I find him comforting. The world, he tells me, even in this one sentence, has danger (it begins) and it also has patterns (as most things begin) and creation (song). Gaiman's epic comic series, Sandman, about the king of dreams and stories, reminded me that storytelling mattered at a time when I had lost faith. His "Make Good Art" speech also reached me at a moment when I needed it. He tells good stories that tell us we can also make art. I need to hear that, now and then.
Keep creating, folks. It matters.
With all my best wishes, Anna
Photo by JOSHUA COLEMAN on Unsplash
David Baldacci appears frequently on bestseller lists. I browsed through a handful of his opening sentences, and this one, from A Minute to Midnight, appealed the most to me: "Once more she rode into the Valley of Death."
That's an operatic and portentous statement. "Once more" – she has done this before, and survived. "She rode" – like a member of the cavalry, or a sheriff in a Western, she is not going or driving, but calling up all the horseback connotations of riding. "Into the Valley of Death" – she is entering a lethally dangerous place, giving up the high ground, and perhaps surrounded by unscalable canyon walls. A valley limits your movement. Armies have an advantage on high ground. So she is not only returning to a very dangerous place, she's giving up her high ground to go there.
"Valley of Death" in this case has three distinct associations. The first comes from one of the most memorized passages of the Bible, the 23rd Psalm. "Yea, though I walk through the Valley of Death, I shall fear no evil." The psalmist also chose "Valley of Death" to describe an extremely perilous situation, which makes God's protection there all the more impressive. The second association is "Death Valley," one of the hottest places on Earth. It is an extremely inhospitable desert. The third association, as we learn in following paragraphs, is with a high security prison, home to murderers, which our heroine is on her way to visit.
The triple meaning must have been irresistible. I find it very appealing.
What kind of woman would return to a Valley of Death? Why go to such a dangerous place? What will happen there?
This sentence is a true hook – it creates intense suspense. The grand voice of the sentence also suggests drama and passion – a promise that the book will deliver more excitement. With these words, David Baldacci launches the book at high speed.
Photo by Will Truettner on Unsplash
The first sentence reads, "Antonia Bennette woke up from her after-school nap to the sound of a guitar." There's no dread or suspense here – we are not afraid of naps or guitars – so this sentence doesn't serve as that kind of hook. It's more like an origin story.
We have a name: Antonia Bennette. She'll go by Toni, later, leaving her with a name that sounds like Tony Bennett, a well-known singer. It's a name that both shows her parents were deeply into music and were a little careless of her. It's unkind to give her a name that will bring an obvious comment throughout her life.
Next, she "woke up." This is literal – she is coming out of sleep – and it could also be metaphorical. Is she having an awakening?
The last two phrases start with "from" and "to." That implies a journey – another clue that this could be a metaphorical awakening as well as a literal one.
And where is she starting? "From her after-school nap." She's young enough to be going to school and to have a nap afterwards.
Where is she going? "To the sound of a guitar." Her awakening is to music.
If I rewrote this sentence as the opening of a fairy tale, it might go like this: "One day, a girl named for a famous musician heard a sound that stirred her." Antonia Bennette is going from youth and sleep to awakening and music. She'll make guitars a core element of her life.
It's a great opening to attract readers who are interested in girls who play guitar and who they grow up to be.
Photo by Leutrim Fetahu on Unsplash
Graphic elements by Ken Silbert
Graphic elements by Ken Silbert
Photo by Yorman Tamayo on Unsplash
The first challenge of a long sentence is making it clear. Gould meets that challenge, with generous deployment of commas and a careful order of words, all following closely together. There's no need to look back at previous parts of the sentence to understand the later parts. There are four sections, each of which almost completes a thought. First, we have a phrase that tells us what "he" is doing: "As he scrubbed one sock in the day's supply of well water;" next, something the character observes: "noting that his stitches had not held and the hole in the toe had reopened;" third, what he is thinking about: "he considered once again the problem of the One Hundred Things;" and finally, how often and how long he has thought about that: "as he had every day, every hour of every day, for the past three years."
By keeping each portion semi-independent, Gould makes the entire sentence easier to follow.
The next challenge of a long sentence is to make it hold attention. Here, the added information of each portion helps. So do the specific details, such as "scrubbed," "day's supply of well water," "hole," and "One Hundred Things." Each of these details is helping build a character – what he does, what he notices, what he thinks, how he does it – in precise terms.
I'm particularly intrigued by "One Hundred Things." The capital letters both show that this is the title of a specific concept and imply that it is important to the character. I happen to have encountered the concept – it's a plan for minimalist living – but would a wide variety of readers know it? Is it a concept that will remain in the current vocabulary a decade from now? Or will it become obscure and tie the character to a specific time? The next sentences do explain the idea, so the story doesn't depend on the reader already knowing what the One Hundred Things are, but it's a less widely known reference than the fairy tales or Shakespeare some of our other first sentences have referred to.
The first section tells us a lot about the character's lifestyle. It includes well water and mending socks. Even paying attention to a hole in a sock puts him out of the mainstream of American life. These are words that go with back-to-the-land living or earlier eras. But "One Hundred Things" seems to date to the book The 100 Thing Challenge, by Dave Bruno, published in 2010. That narrows the possible period for this story.
The final portion of the sentence, placed where it will receive the most emphasis, is the most intense. "As he had every day, every hour of every day, for the past three years." That's a frequency of thought that suits matters of survival: sex or food or living with a predator. Somehow, the One Hundred Things have become the equivalent of life-and-death to this character. The repetition of "every" is a poetic device, showing the return of the word like the return of the thought. The constant focus on One Hundred Things is an obsession.
I found the character intriguing. I was a little unsure through the book whether the narrator admired or had contempt for this obsession, and I also was unclear on the tone of the book at times. That's okay. An occasional ambiguous read is a pleasant stretch. It feels fresh, now and then, for an author to leave their judgments complex.
Graphic elements by Ken Silbert
Photo by Taylor Simpson on Unsplash
Photo by Courtney Rose on Unsplash
Photo by Erol Ahmed on Unsplash
Other genres may have other priorities for first sentences. Or possibly it's the other way around: A first sentence may start to build the genre of a story. Revealing genre is a fast way to set a frame around a story. Withholding genre asks the reader to keep an open mind a little longer – and most of the books that do that are literary or mainstream fiction.
Alexandra Rowland begins her novel A Conspiracy of Truths with this sentence: "The whole mess began in a courtroom in Vsila, the capital of Nuryevet, where I was being put on trial for something stupid."
The first words of the sentence, "The whole mess began," tell us that the narrator plans to start at the beginning of a problem. They also are informal speech. They are everyday language, without the tradition of "Once upon a time," or the pastoral tones of "In the beginning," or the military precision of "At 2100 hours on the seventh day of the third month...." "Mess," in particular, is a word more often spoken than written. These four words both announce the beginning and begin to build a voice.
The next few words, "in a courtroom," lets us know that this is a legal tale. We begin to expect lawyers and juries and laws.
Then we have "in Vsila, the capital of Nuryevet." These are places I have never heard of. The form suggests that Nuryevet is a country, and Vsila its governing city, so these are significant places rather than obscure ones – in the world they belong to, which is not our world and our time. The two place names have a vaguely Russian or eastern European feel to them. For those who remember the Cold War, that feel makes the word "courtroom" more chilling.
The next words, "where I was being put on trial," raise the stakes. Now the narrator ("I") is not attending the courtroom as an audience member or a lawyer – they are the defendant, and thus at risk of whatever the penalties may be for what they are accused of.
The sentence ends with these words, "for something stupid." The narrator doesn't respect the charges. In fact, they call them "stupid," which might even show contempt for the charges or the court.
The narrator has a lot of attitude.
This sentence starts and ends with words that build the narrator's voice. In the middle, it shows that we are in a different world ("Vsila," "Nuryevet"), and puts the narrator in jeopardy ("where I was on trial"). The strong final word underlines that the narrator has a bad opinion of the court, or the law that accuses them. What kind of person dares speak badly of the law? Someone who thinks themselves outside it.
This is a story of person against the system. Because the sentence is in first person, past tense, we know the narrator will survive to tell the tale about "the whole mess."
For a clue to the genre, we see that the story takes place in a different world. This suggests fantasy or science fiction. There's no sign yet of magic, which would make this fantasy, or advanced technology, which would make this science fiction. It will take more sentences to determine that part of the genre.
The first sentence has told us quite a lot about the story to come. It will feature a person with attitude who prevails against the system in another world. If you like that kind of story, this first sentence is telling us, you will like this book.
I do like that kind of story and I did like the book. A Conspiracy of Truths delivers what it promises from the first sentence.
Graphic elements by Ken Silbert
This morning, with some ideas about what I might say about the sentence, I read the book. The book gives the sentence a different meaning than I'd taken as I considered the first sentence on its own. I'd expected the story of an illness. I took "For a long time, my mother wasn't dead yet," to mean that everyone had known the mother was going to die for a long time before she did. My best guess was cancer or some lingering wasting disease.
I have a good imagination. I can roll out long stories from small clues. Sometimes I'm wrong. This was one of those cases.
What the narrator meant could be a spoiler, so I will not tell it here. I will drop the expectation of a long illness and see what's in the first sentence itself.
There are two characters: the speaker and the speaker's mother. The mother is "my mother" – very close to the person who tells the story. There are markers of time: "For a long time" and "yet." "For a long time" means this situation stretched out. "Yet" marks the end of that duration, and it is a short, sharp clip of a word. "Yet" breaks the long stretch decisively.
There is also a problem. "For a long time, my mother was not dead yet," is in the past tense. That past tense implies that, although there was a long period before she died, the mother is dead now.
It's a short sentence, full of short words. The longest is "mother." "Mother" and "dead" are both very strong words, full of associations and emotions. Together, they worry us.
The part of the sentence that most matches the rest of the book is "For a long time." There is a feeling of suspension, of pending grief or loss that continues throughout the story. Although the first sentence misled me a bit, the tone and the worry of it begin creating the mood that will hold throughout the novel.
Graphic elements by Ken Silbert
Her novel, Spoiler Alert, starts with this sentence: "Between takes, Marcus did his best not to acknowledge the obvious: this was a stupid-ass way to die."
Let's start at the end this time. The word "die" is here, placed in the strong, final position that gives a word extra emphasis. Normally, this would create high tension, as "die" raises the stakes to life or death. However, this sentence undercuts the tension of the word. "Between takes" means that this is make-believe: Marcus is part of a video production. Worse, "stupid-ass way to die" suggests that it is a badly written death scene.
Marcus is a character with a problem. It's not the threat to his life that the word "die" might at first suggest. Instead, it is something that takes quite a few more words to describe. He must "do his best not to acknowledge" – that is, he must play his death straight – that this is "a stupid-ass way to die." His problem is not that he is going to die. His problem is that he needs to commit to a scene that doesn't make sense to him.
Now we know a lot about Marcus. He's an actor – that is almost certain to bring with it that he is attractive. In this world, professional actors are very seldom unattractive. He's intellectual – he has noticed that the death scene is a stupid one, and his thinking about it is complex: "did his best not to acknowledge the obvious" is a layered thought with a long word in it. He's a little snarky: "stupid-ass" is a bold and impolite term. Many writers stick to more moderate language.
Attractive, intelligent, snarky – Marcus has the attributes of a romantic hero. He's also trying to keep a secret – that he knows this scene is bad.
"Die" is a strong word. The sentence before it subverts its meaning, so that instead of enhancing fear, the strength of the word enhances the humor of the sentence. Marcus does have a problem, but it is an artistic problem rather than a survival problem. The sentence spends most of its words showing who Marcus is in an indirect fashion.
Give me those implications! I really like learning about characters from their thoughts and actions. It's no wonder I keep buying all Olivia Dade's books.
It's very hot today, and my proofreader is away. Please forgive any typos or reduced clarity. You can tell me about them! And I will correct them later.
Wishing you all comfort and safety, Anna
Photo by Jonathan Kemper on Unsplash
Graphic elements by Ken Silbert
There's a life-threatening situation in this sentence: "as he faced the firing squad." However, it is placed gently in the middle of the sentence, with words directing our attention elsewhere on either side of it. The opening of the sentence, "Many years later," places the firing squad at a distant time – although the firing squad is deadly, it isn't happening now, which makes it much less urgent. Humans tend to discount future problems. What can be done, now, about something that will happen many years later?
The last part of the sentence also softens the tension. When faced with the firing squad, the main character doesn't scream or cry or beg or sweat. He "was to remember" – he thought of his past. That could be an escape or a way to grieve what he is losing. It is a mental action rather than a physical action. Remembering can connect to any emotion. It is neutral until we know more. Because it is neutral and internal, it also reduces the tension of facing the firing squad.
Notice also how the sentence telescopes through time. There are three time periods in the sentence. One is the implied present – a time many years before the firing squad. The second is the day of the firing squad, many years after the present. The third time is "that distant afternoon" when Colonel Aureliano Buendia was a boy. The sentence stretches from boyhood, through adulthood, to probable death. It covers the length of a life.
"Colonel Aureliano Buendia" suggests a man of power. He holds rank. He receives the respect of a long, full name. Aureliano might tie to Marcus Aurelius, the stoic emperor of the Roman empire. Buendia breaks down into buen dia, a fortunate day. These names, too, suggest good fortune and strength. They are clues that he had a strong prime of life. The stretched time of the sentence suggests his life was long, as well.
The childhood memory that he will return to is "when his father took him to discover ice." For contemporary North American readers, ice is too common to discover. It is in our drinks and in our freezers since before we retain memories. To discover ice, it must be something the boy had not yet encountered – something rare. If we didn't know ice, what a wonder it would be. This is a good memory: a father taking a child on a wondrous yet safe adventure. Because the boy didn't yet know ice, he may be quite young. The times in this sentence may begin with his earliest memories, cross the peak of his influence, and end with his death.
I haven't completed this book. The sentences are lovely, and I was feeling too impatient for the wandering strategy of the story. I think, like the first sentence, the entire story wants to embrace a wide view, not only of time, but of character and place. I do think the first sentence shows a very interesting technique. It contains the basic elements of a hook – a character in a high tension situation – and then chooses to look at a much longer period of time, letting the tension slip away in favor of detail and nostalgia. When would this be the perfect entry into a story?
Graphic elements by Ken Silbert
She starts the story like this: "Once upon a time, there was a boy born with frost in his eyes and frost in his heart."
I've had a good, long day helping others solve writing problems. I'm going to indulge myself and try something a little different with today's first sentence post.
My usual practice is to see how much I can draw out of the sentence on its own. Then I may discover that a single word has so many ties to custom, nature, and literature that it pulls all the universe into my discussion of a single sentence.
On the other hand, there are sometimes sentences that I decide not to review because they don't fit the rest of the book. I usually read the entire book before I write about its first sentence here. If the first sentence sets my expectations wrongly for the rest of the book, or turns out to be of a different quality or a different tone than the rest of the book, I pass on it. After all, I like to show good first sentences, and part of what makes a good first sentence is that it opens the door to the world of the story. A misleading sentence doesn't serve that purpose.
How can I talk about the fit between a sentence and the rest of the book, when it takes me paragraphs to discuss a sentence alone? I'll need to take a broader view. It helps that The Raven and the Reindeer is inspired by Hans Christian Andersen's story, "The Snow Queen," which is somewhat well-known and in the public domain, so you can consult it if you wish.
The sentence starts with a time stamp, "Once upon a time," which puts us in mythic time. Then it gives us a character, "a boy was born," and a possible problem "with frost in his eyes and frost in his heart." That last portion has a lovely parallel construction.
What does it mean to have "frost in his eyes?" We soon discover that the boy, named Kay, has both pale eyes and eyes that see the world critically. What does it mean to have "frost in his heart?" We have a phrase, cold-hearted, that is similar. It means to have little care for others. The story reveals that this is true of Kay – and he also cherishes snow – so much so, that one day, he approaches a sorceress of snow and lets her take him away, without a thought for his family and friends.
The bulk of the story follows Gerta, the neighbor girl who is devoted to him, and how she journeys to bring him home again.
So I could talk about how the words "boy" and "heart" in the sentence suggest that we will look at first love. Does this match the story line of the book? In playful ways, it does, for Gerta pushes herself through great hazards to find Kay.
Then there's the word "frost," appearing twice. The book continues with many images of frost and snow and ice. It talks about the cold, both of the weather and the heart, and how to survive it.
"Eyes" in the first sentence begins an entire thread of visions and how people see and don't, continued throughout the story. "Heart," too, is the start of a series on what people feel or don't, and how they act on it.
"Once upon a time" promises us an enchanted world, and the story generously fulfills it with strange magics and arcane sights. There are gorgeous set pieces here, like the reindeer road and the Snow Queen's castle of ice, that are marvels that still feel an organic piece of this world.
In short, this first sentence is an excellent microcosm of the story to come. It has been a true pleasure for me to reflect on it and how well it fits with the story it opens.
Graphic elements by Ken Silbert
Photo by Raisa Milova on Unsplash
In the meanwhile, my list of ready-to-blog sentences was running low. In honor of Pride month, I decided to browse Wikipedia's list of LGBTQ authors for inspiration. I was happy to find Catherine Ryan Hyde there, like an old friend. Where We Belong is the first book of hers I read. I've gone on to read a dozen more.
The first sentence of Where We Belong by Catherine Ryan Hyde is: "By the time I was seven, I had twenty-two packs of playing cards."
This one is a seduction. It doesn't have the tension of a hook. Twenty-two packs of playing cards is unusual – a bit of mystery – but not dangerous. It isn't a promise – I don't detect another book it references or a strong marker of genre. There are poetic techniques to create beauty.
The first part of the sentence has four long "i" sounds: in by, time, I, and I. They come quickly. It's a long vowel sound, creating a bit of suspension in the rhythm of the opening. Try saying it aloud: "By the time I was seven, I...." These long vowels are hard to rush over. They ask us to slow down and savor.
The next portion of the sentence contains a number with three quick "t" sounds: twenty-two. It's the most alliterative number under fifty – I counted through them to check. Then we have two "p" sounds for another quick alliteration: "packs of playing cards." I almost always call these "decks of cards." Hyde made the choice to include "playing," which she could have left out, and to use "packs" rather than "decks."
The stressed syllables of the sentence do not fall into a regular pattern. I hear the first section as falling in triplets, then the second section in irregular pairs. It's a rhythm that catches attention without monotony.
Poetic devices like repeated sounds and ear-catching rhythms most often go with sentences in my seduction category.
Within a few paragraphs of this first sentence, there are events that could have created high tension. Hyde chose to start more quietly.
The sentence contains one character, "I." "Before I was seven years old," places the sentence in the formative past – here is an early childhood situation that influenced the character. The situation is "had twenty-two packs of playing cards." That's unusual. Twenty-two is more packs than most people need, especially at seven years old. We do wonder why the narrator had so many cards, so young. That's a call to our curiosity, rather than to fear or excitement – a gentler invitation to read on, which is another reason this sentence seems a seduction rather than a hook to me.
But maybe Hyde knew hooks could be gentle. After all, I read this book and twelve more of hers. I do seem hooked enough.
Photo by Klim Musalimov on Unsplash
Graphic elements by Ken Silbert